Impact to Ecosystem?

screaminleeman

Jack Dempsey
MFK Member
Nov 27, 2009
1,445
10
38
Westminster, MD
I have gotten some feedback on the potential to infect the local ecosystem by stocking outdoor ponds with non-native fish such as Koi etc.

I think every outdoor Koi Keeper has experienced loss from Bird, Snake and Mammal in that endeavour! It did start me to thinking (Dangerous) if it is not completely impossible to avoid and the very hobby of keeping tropical fish innately irresponsible.

I can right off the top of my head think of MANY possible challenges that the hobby of Tropical fish keeping could present to the local ecosystem.

1. When we do water changes in our tank, where does this water go? In the rural areas the drains run into a septic tank then through a drain-field. While septic might kill some parasites and diseases, it no doubt can not handle them all, and the surviving strains will become even more powerful. Local worms will absorb these Protozoan parasites and spread them to hungry birds etc. It is even worse considering the same situation in urban areas with the sewage system setup!

2. When treating fish disease, it is common practice to discard infected water as part of the "fish cure". How is this known contaminated water responsibly dealt with?

3. When fish die of disease, it is common practice to either flush, or discard the infected remains. How does this not directly affect the ecosystem?

Any thoughts on how to minimize the dangers?:eek:
 

Lupin

Viviendo la vida loca!
MFK Member
1. I think you are blanketing there too much. Not everyone dumps the water straight to the septic. Some people dump them into gardens as the nitrate loaded water is beneficial to their plants and crops however contaminated water (by series of medicines) should be dumped to the drain to avoid endangering your health. Some treatments are known carcinogenic agents particularly methylene blue, formalin and malachite green.

Some aquatic parasites cannot survive outside water. Others cannot morph to a stage that will allow them to host terrestrial animals therefore that is kind of a moot point. I do not think this is a common occurrence at all and at the point that most of our fish are bred in captivity, there is very minimal risk of transmitting diseases that phase into various forms with some able to infect humans, birds and rodents that come in contact with the fish.

2. Pardon? I am not getting the second statement. In my case, I simply discard the contaminated water to the drain or garden. Again, there is very little risk of parasite transmission. A lot of parasites cannot survive without fish as their hosts.

3. I doubt it. Most people just bury them in the garden, throw them straight into the trash can or incinerate them. Dead animals make good fertilizers so burying is practical. I won't deny some people flush them into the toilet out of pure habit. The scenario of strains of parasites getting more resistant to chemicals is no different from strains of parasites that humans contract and expel through their wastes. Honestly, I do not see any cause for concern here.
 

screaminleeman

Jack Dempsey
MFK Member
Nov 27, 2009
1,445
10
38
Westminster, MD
Thanks Lupin.

The reason that I ask, is that "gotten some feedback" was more got totally lambasted on a different site for transferring Channel Catfish from aquarium after getting large to my farm pond. I did not think that I was Once-ler, but sure got laid out for it by hordes of Lorax(s).:WHOA:
 
zoomed.com
hikariusa.com
aqaimports.com
Store