I think the colors are pretty similar, maybe look a bit different due to lighting or Whatever. Mine is getting more yellow/orange with age and diet change. I think as these continue to grow and mature, they will take on more of that pale yellow with orange/red fins. I have changed his diet over the past couple months, adding in more Massivore pellets stuffed into pieces of salmon .I wonder why yours is still keeping the whiteness better than others, like this one: https://www.monsterfishkeepers.com/forums/threads/phantom-redtail.746296/