Jaguar or Flowerhorn?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Personally I'd go for a jag if you can get a big enough tank, if not go for a motaguense like the other guys have said, there a cool little fish with bags of personality
 
Are you looking for a wet pet of sorts? I second the Motaguense recommendation, they're basically a smaller, red Jag. If you're looking for a big personality then you'd be hard pressed to find a better suggestion than a flowerhorn for that sized tank.
Yeah I've been looking for a sort of wet pet since I can't get a tank larger than 150 gallons. I looked up the montaguense and they looked really stunning. I'm still not sure if I'm a fan of the flowerhorn kok, so the montaguense might be a really good alternative if I decide against a flowerhorn.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kewpiefishypewpie
Here are some other options that would be fine solo in a 125-150 long term
N. Tetracanthus
C. Grammodes
C. Istlanum
V. Breidohri
A. Saggitae/Citrinellum/lyonsi/labiatus/trimaculatus (any amphilophus really)
H. Carpintis

Seriously good suggestions here. Breidohri are arguably the most colorful cichlid one can own, one of my personal favorites.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gourami Swami
Out of all the fish suggested I think I've narrowed my choices down to either a flowerhorn or V. Breidohri. Unless the V. Breidohri could be mixed with a pleco and maybe a few other similarly sized fish I'll probably just go for the flowerhorn and have a single wet pet.
 
Breidohri could be kept with a pleco for sure. Similarly sized fish would be do-able but difficult to get a mix that works in this sized tank. Could pretty easily be kept with some smaller species like Honduran red points or Salvini.
Something like 1 breidohri, 1 pleco (commons get huge- smaller fancy would be better), 5 Honduran red points would probably work out fine. 150 would be better if you wanted to try this, 125 would be do-able as well just have to keep up on maintenance when the fish are all large.
 
Ok thanks for all the input guys. The more I think about it I think it would be best if I waited a few years before I set up a cichlid community tank so I can do a larger tank and have more experience keeping large aggressive Cichlids. I think in the meantime though I'll stick with my original intention of getting a flowerhorn as my first big cichlid.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gourami Swami
Get both it's not hard.

Flowerhorns of course.
And I've kept them both. Jags are cool too but I breed FHs and Jags can't sell like FHs. People like FHs because it's a package of many goodies
 
  • Like
Reactions: Reaper169666
Get both it's not hard.

Flowerhorns of course.
And I've kept them both. Jags are cool too but I breed FHs and Jags can't sell like FHs. People like FHs because it's a package of many goodies
Any luck keeping Flowerhorns with other fish? I would love to keep a flowerhorn with some kind of fancy pleco, but I've heard flowerhorns will kill anything else in the tank unless you have a huge tank.
 
I've kept them with other aggressive fish, Amphilophus and Vieja. I wouldn't recommend it based on my personal experience but I reckon a pleco would be fine.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com