Carbon filter in aquarium

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

orouborus

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Oct 20, 2009
29
0
0
Philippines
hi all,

i have a carbon filter media and i would like to know if it is ok to place it inside the aquarium with gars? or should i just put it in the filter box with other filters? is it harmful for them?

thanks!
 
Activated carbon only works for about 3 days, then it has done all its going to do and would need to be changed.

Activated carbon is good for a few things, clearing meds out of a tank that has recently been treated, helping to remove tannins from water stained by drift wood or as a preventative measure when airborn chemicals are in the house (think flea bomb). Another advantage to it is to help polish your water just a little more to help make pictures look just a little better when you are planning a photo shoot. It really has NO day to day function.

It won't hurt your fish and I would keep some on hand to use if I need it at all times. I have a large container of it in the basement lying in wait, but there is NON in any of my tanks. It would cost a fortune to replace it every three days. I do have a tank badly stained by drift wood tannins, but weekly 50% water changes solve that problem for about 4 days a week, every week. If it really bothered me, I would do 50% water changed 2x a week.
 
kdrun76;3615982; said:
Activated carbon only works for about 3 days, then it has done all its going to do and would need to be changed.

Activated carbon is good for a few things, clearing meds out of a tank that has recently been treated, helping to remove tannins from water stained by drift wood or as a preventative measure when airborn chemicals are in the house (think flea bomb). Another advantage to it is to help polish your water just a little more to help make pictures look just a little better when you are planning a photo shoot. It really has NO day to day function.

It won't hurt your fish and I would keep some on hand to use if I need it at all times. I have a large container of it in the basement lying in wait, but there is NON in any of my tanks. It would cost a fortune to replace it every three days. I do have a tank badly stained by drift wood tannins, but weekly 50% water changes solve that problem for about 4 days a week, every week. If it really bothered me, I would do 50% water changed 2x a week.

thanks for the tip! hmm... i dont think i have that many carbon filters, so water changing is good for me as well. :nilly: yeah drift woods do stain water a lot...

thanks!
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com