First, both pictured FH' s look to be very good quality fish. Regarding the type, as noted above, who knows? IMO the juvenile FH looks older than two months. Color preference is subjective. What works for one doesn't always work for others. As noted above, there are better FH' s out there, but is it worth paying $200 for a more colorful fish or pay $50 for a slightly less colorful one. It's your call. I say if you can buy it on the cheap, go for it.