Moving giant piraiba catfish

Kingdoffishcraft

Plecostomus
MFK Member
Sep 9, 2019
165
218
51
I'm planning on moving a piraiba from a fiberglass pond to a outdoor lake. He's 35 inches and has outgrown his current home. However, I've heard rumors of the catfish being notoriously hard to move. They seem to die when being netted out due to stress. Is there a way to work around this? Any tips on moving such a large catfish? Does clove oil help?

It's about an hours drive.
 

deeda

Silver Tier VIP
MFK Member
Mar 26, 2008
4,083
3,039
1,279
Medina, Ohio
You have an outdoor lake?
 

Kingdoffishcraft

Plecostomus
MFK Member
Sep 9, 2019
165
218
51
Shouldn’t release your own aquarium pets into the wild, It is harmful to the ecosystem. If it has grown too big for your tank donate it away or give it to someone who can take care of it.
Its my private stocked reservoir. With arapaima, gars and other large species of fish. It's disconnected from major water ways. So no worries there. But I wanted to move this guy for a while but have been reluctant due to the fact that they die easily.
 

thebiggerthebetter

Senior Curator
Staff member
MFK Member
Dec 31, 2009
16,293
14,499
3,910
Naples, FL, USA
I think you must be referring to a (hearsay?) phenomenon that exists in Asian fish forums about the tig catfish, that is that they die from stress of just being moved between tanks, of being netted and taken out of water. Asian Exotics Asian Exotics I heard it from our peer Cy, whom I am tagging, the one and only time I came across this. I didn't believe this. Then, over 1.5 years I lost 6 adult tigs. I still do not think this was due to the move at all. I had other completely unrelated fish die in that tank with the same exact symptoms. However, this doesn't rule out the stress that could have weakened tigs' immune system and thus they were overcome by the same infection as those other tank mates and died over 1.5 year period, 6 out of 8. Two are still ok. Anyhow, this sounds like a long stretch, but cannot be ruled out completely.

So, as for the tigs, IDK, I don't believe this, it doesn't sound plausible but I cannot prove it.

If you are extending this fear onto the genus-kin of tig, that is the piraiba, that'd be a first for me to hear this.

IME I haven't had any problems moving piraiba from tank to tank even at 3 feet, as yours is, you can see our videos on how we do it on our channel (type pillowcase and blanket case in the search). But never long distance, just from tank to tank in our facility.

Clove oil always helps, for sure. The fear is overdosing and euthanizing the fish. Err on the safe side I'd say. And use the largest transport container you can afford, if you value the fish a lot. Like even rent a truck / van that can carry 250 gallons of water in say a 500 gal tub.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kingdoffishcraft

Kingdoffishcraft

Plecostomus
MFK Member
Sep 9, 2019
165
218
51
I think you must be referring to a (hearsay?) phenomenon that exists in Asian fish forums about the tig catfish, that is that they die from stress of just being moved between tanks, of being netted and taken out of water. Asian Exotics Asian Exotics I heard it from our peer Cy, whom I am tagging, the one and only time I came across this. I didn't believe this. Then, over 1.5 years I lost 6 adult tigs. I still do not think this was due to the move at all. I had other completely unrelated fish die in that tank with the same exact symptoms. However, this doesn't rule out the stress that could have weakened tigs' immune system and thus they were overcome by the same infection as those other tank mates and died over 1.5 year period, 6 out of 8. Two are still ok. Anyhow, this sounds like a long stretch, but cannot be ruled out completely.

So, as for the tigs, IDK, I don't believe this, it doesn't sound plausible but I cannot prove it.

If you are extending this fear onto the genus-kin of tig, that is the piraiba, that'd be a first for me to hear this.

IME I haven't had any problems moving piraiba from tank to tank even at 3 feet, as yours is, you can see our videos on how we do it on our channel (type pillowcase and blanket case in the search). But never long distance, just from tank to tank in our facility.

Clove oil always helps, for sure. The fear is overdosing and euthanizing the fish. Err on the safe side I'd say. And use the largest transport container you can afford, if you value the fish a lot. Like even rent a truck / van that can carry 250 gallons of water in say a 500 gal tub.
Thanks for the recommendation!!! I'll try to use your tactics to move my big baby. Hopefully everything goes well!!
 
zoomed.com
hikariusa.com
aqaimports.com
Store