Well said dear.I go to Absolutely Fish over in Clifton, NJ. They are one of the better stores I been too around here. They have a nice setup and a good variety of fishes.
Fish Hut in Saddle Brook is also worth a visit if you got the time. Not that far off the GSP.
If you want something in particular, you could probably ask them to special order it for ya. Probably could do that at most places though.