Parachromis Dovii Water Hardness

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Roger Mcfish

Piranha
MFK Member
Dec 2, 2023
295
351
77
42
I know these fish come from hard water. What is an acceptable hardness level for them to thrive in if they are tank raised and nowhere near wild caught?

Is 158ppm in hardness acceptable for them?
 
While dovii are found all over Costa Rica in rivers and lakes that usually have pH around 7.5, calcium rich, lake Arenal where they are coveted by sport fishermen, is an enigma. The pH can sometimes drop below 7, and water is quite cold, only around 70"F, and can drop lower.
In mosr rivers nitrates are < 5 ppm, but in Arenal, probably because of agriculture and commercial ferilizer use, and sewage dumped into it nitrate can be quite high

I kept my dovii in mid 70s temps, at a pH of @ 7.8, and moderate hardness.
They went from 2" juvies to over 12" in about a year.
1743085884868.png1743085905144.png
I visited Lake Arenal a few times in the mid 90s and was surprised to find it as cold as it was.
And fishermen said they had more luck with large insects as bait rather than fish like tetras.
Below a breakdown of Lake Arenal data

Lake Arenal, Costa Rica, has a depth that varies seasonally between 30 and 60 meters (100-200 feet), and its water temperature varies less than 4 degrees Fahrenheit year-round.

Here's a more detailed breakdown of Lake Arenal's water parameters:
  • Size and Depth: Lake Arenal is the largest lake in Costa Rica, covering 85 square kilometers (33 sq mi) and with a depth that varies seasonally between 30 and 60 meters (100-200 feet).

  • Water Temperature: Water temperature varies less than 4 degrees Fahrenheit year-round.

  • Water Quality: While Costa Rica emphasizes environmental conservation, surface water quality can be affected by factors like untreated sewage and agricultural runoff.

  • Water Use: The lake is a source of water for both hydroelectric power generation and irrigation projects.

  • Turbidity: Turbidity was elevated (17.30–78.90 NTU)

  • pH: The pH was within 6.86–7.49

  • Nitrates and Phosphates: Elevated nitrates (8.0–50.0 mg/L) and phosphates (1.0–9.0 mg/L) were detected at all five sites
 
A number of fish species share lake Arenal with the dovii, and many are also found here in Panama.
IMG_3519.jpegIMG_2643.jpegIMG_4176.jpeg
Above are the tetra, Brycon guatamalemmsus, the ones I've cough are just juvies
IMG_3665.jpeg
IMG_4027.jpeg
Some other species found in the lake are a couple Centropomis species (snook (here called rabalo))
IMG_9828.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Done45 and tlindsey
One of the things that interested me about the lake, because all the raw sewage that is run directly into it,
was how the fish (such as dovii) were able to survive in those elevated nitrate and phosphate levels, that might normally cause hypoxia, (the the inabilty to process dissolved oxygen in water).

But cooler water can hold higher amounts of disolved oxygen than warmer water, so those fish adapted over time, to tolerate low 70" F water temps may provide a slight advantage .with the elevated pollutants
 
  • Like
Reactions: Done45 and tlindsey
MonsterFishKeepers.com