Pond vs Tank - The Great Debate

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

polish

Jack Dempsey
MFK Member
Jun 9, 2008
2,148
3
38
Ne, IN
www.tankterrors.com
Well as with many things in life I am having second thoughts, this time about my pond. (Click link in sig to see it)

I just really don't care for it. It kind of takes the fun out of fish keeping. It's kind of like having a tiny lake or something. The fish can retreat away and if I am blessed with their presence I get to see the top of them, weeee... Also they get spooked much easier because they can't see me coming like they can in a tank.

Anyone else have this sort of feeling after building a pond?

I can no longer photograph any of these fish because the water is never perfectly still (Not an issue in a tank since you're photographing through Glass/Acrylic but with a pond you're photographing it through the water surface) and even if I could it would again be an overhead shot only. This is a big problem for me... I really like taking photographs of the fish and didn't realize how much photo ability is lost with the pond.

I could fix some of these issues with a viewing window but I just don't think it would be worth the work. I would be limited then to that small viewing window and knowing my luck it would leak anyway, so I doubt I'd try.

So now you can see my dilemma... The pond itself looks cool but the fish inside may as well not even be there. I can't see them for squat. I did think about it before hand but instead of wondering how it would be I decided to just build it and see how I liked it, thus far - not so much. Now I see why people stick to keeping Koi in ponds, they look pretty cool from the top and will come to the top to feed. A pond full of Bichirs and Cichlids - not so much really.

Here are what the options I've come up with.

1. Use the pond as a stand/sump and stick a 6' tank on top of it. This way I can put some fish in the tank and actually enjoy them. Some of the bigger ones would have to stay in the pond/sump though - which I don't like.
2. Take the pond out all together and build a rack system for a few tanks. I have a 7'x4' foot print to work with. So I could do a 180g++ on the bottom and a couple medium/smaller tanks up top...
3. Take the pond out and replace it with a stand then just do one monster tank, around 300 or so gallons... Problem is I am limited to 7', so unless I find a 6x3 or 7x3 this isn't gonna happen.
4. Light it on fire, see what happens? :nilly:
5. ???


So yea, any thoughts?
 
I'de go w/ 1 big tank or like you said 2x 180's or similar... Only other suggestion would be to find some other stock for it that are better viewed from above.. but I have the feeling since you mentioned koi.. and not another ponder for new fish. You want to keep your current stock. Can't say I blame you either.

I would prolly look into doing a DIY acrylic tank over the existing pond, useing it as a sump as you stated. Not sure how.. but I'd prolly figure out some way to tie it altogether into a form of sectioned system. giving the cichlids talller sections and then shorter systems for the bichirs ect. The name of the systems elludes me atm. but I've seen a few done and they are very interesting ways to showcase the fish and the entire unit is very appealing if done right. suppose depends on how much you ant to put into such a project. but it would give you a few options for housing, and still give you areas to photograph, watch things.
 
polish;4204918;4204918 said:
I've seen it for sale but unfortunately I live about 2200 miles away from him. ;)
road trip!! :headbang2
 
A window in that bad boy would be awesome, or build a large acrylic tank up top (same footprint would be awesome) and use it as a sump!
 
There's a reason ponds are not for everyone... and not all fish are good for ponds. I'd always recommend someone keeping goldfish/Koi in a pond first to see if they like the pond concept first before keeping other fish such as cichlids.

Ponds are mostly only good for larger size whereas tanks are good for viewing
 
snake_charmer has a 150 gallon (wide) but it in MI. :(
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com