Is it really necessary to perform surgery? I dont have exp at this task.I would be inclined to say that it's not any type of fungus or disease at this point. It may have been at some time, but it should have grown back by now if it happened months ago. Like Tig suggested, you may have to perform some cosmetic surgery if you want it to grow back right. Or, if the fish isn't showing any adverse side effects, you could just leave it.