Are My Oscars Breeding?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Calvin4924

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Jun 28, 2018
27
16
8
25
I have a pair of oscars in a 100gal. I've had them since they were and inch long and they've always been inseparable. now they're about 10 inches long. Recently my ph has been too low so I've started doing water changes more frequently and working to stabilize. One of the oscars has started biting and slamming into the other, and they often lock mouths and spin eachother around. I assume this is a breeding display because they spend the other half their time sitting next to each other with no shown aggression. however, Oscar that is the "victim" of the aggression is recovering from a sore on their gill plate and torn fins (my ph went downhill fast and i didnt notice right away) and is now showing what appear to be bruises and scratches on its head that I think are a result of the scuffles. He still eats and defends himself. Should I be concerned?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Matteus
I have a pair of oscars in a 100gal. I've had them since they were and inch long and they've always been inseparable. now they're about 10 inches long. Recently my ph has been too low so I've started doing water changes more frequently and working to stabilize. One of the oscars has started biting and slamming into the other, and they often lock mouths and spin eachother around. I assume this is a breeding display because they spend the other half their time sitting next to each other with no shown aggression. however, Oscar that is the "victim" of the aggression is recovering from a sore on their gill plate and torn fins (my ph went downhill fast and i didnt notice right away) and is now showing what appear to be bruises and scratches on its head that I think are a result of the scuffles. He still eats and defends himself. Should I be concerned?




Yes it sounds like breeding behavior and water changes will trigger this. Have you noticed any digging of the substrate?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Matteus
Yes it sounds like breeding behavior and water changes will trigger this. Have you noticed any digging of the substrate?
not more than usual. although there are plenty of flat stones for them to use if they want. Should I be concerned about the bruises and a couple missing scales?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Matteus
I have a pair of oscars in a 100gal. I've had them since they were and inch long and they've always been inseparable. now they're about 10 inches long. Recently my ph has been too low so I've started doing water changes more frequently and working to stabilize. One of the oscars has started biting and slamming into the other, and they often lock mouths and spin eachother around. I assume this is a breeding display because they spend the other half their time sitting next to each other with no shown aggression. however, Oscar that is the "victim" of the aggression is recovering from a sore on their gill plate and torn fins (my ph went downhill fast and i didnt notice right away) and is now showing what appear to be bruises and scratches on its head that I think are a result of the scuffles. He still eats and defends himself. Should I be concerned?
Do you know how to vent the oscars? If you haven’t already, that could be a start to even see if they are compatible sexually. If not Jexnell Jexnell can help you out with sexing them.

O’s like many chiclids are funny when it comes to breeding, sometimes it’s hard to say if they are about to spawn or fight to the death. I agree with what tlindsey tlindsey said about separating them. I went through the same behaviour with my pair, had to separate and the female later died of the stress and injury.

Another thought that no one really wants to hear is it may actually be a battle for space, a 100 gal is a big tank but it might be starting to get crowded with 2 -10” o’s. I am pretty sure this is what happened with mine at roughly 6” in a 70 gal.

Either way keep us posted.
 
Easiest way to sex an Oscar is to tease them with food at the waters surface. Till they are in a near vertical position. Then grab some pictures of thier vent area.
20171221_010617.jpg 20171221_010658.jpg
Then use the zoom function in editing to really zoom in to the area in question. 20171221_210714.jpg
Males these holes are simular in size. Females you can see the back one is bigger than the front.Oscar_fish_sexual_organs.jpg
 
Do you know how to vent the oscars? If you haven’t already, that could be a start to even see if they are compatible sexually. If not Jexnell Jexnell can help you out with sexing them.

O’s like many chiclids are funny when it comes to breeding, sometimes it’s hard to say if they are about to spawn or fight to the death. I agree with what tlindsey tlindsey said about separating them. I went through the same behaviour with my pair, had to separate and the female later died of the stress and injury.

Another thought that no one really wants to hear is it may actually be a battle for space, a 100 gal is a big tank but it might be starting to get crowded with 2 -10” o’s. I am pretty sure this is what happened with mine at roughly 6” in a 70 gal.

Either way keep us posted.
It appears I have a male and a female. The female fish is the one initiating most of the aggression and breeding behavior.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com