I havent kept Blue Dempseys in 10 years. So I'm not sure if they've gotten worse since then.
So even a known weak breed, if well cared for can have a wonderful life.
Something we should remember with all our fish purchases...
A fish that produces 400 offspring per brood, throws a ton of genetic diversity across the group. This is an evolutionary trait that helps them adapt to a changing environment. Not all offspring are ment to survive.
In aquaria, we keep most of them alive anyway. So, we shouldn't expect every fish in the broad to be prime stock.
Thats why its best to get a group, then keep the best of that group. The larger the group, the higher your chances of getting prime stock.
In my experience, prime Blue Dempseys will gain full size, be tough/aggressive, maintain health and be beautiful. But, this may only be the top 1%, where other species may see those qualities in the top 40%.
So my solution was, starting with as large of a group as possible and/or getting groups from multiple breeders.
Blue Dempseys aren't for the faint of heart. Be prepared to buy a bunch, cull most of them and start over if your first group doesn't pan out.