Weld-On #4, but if it's hard to find, Loctite Marine Epoxy also works. Home Depot has it.
Reef-keepers sometimes use marine epoxies to attach coral frags inside their tanks. It dries non-toxic, at least, I haven't heard of any problems. Note for looks: the epoxy dries to a pale gray color. And it's pretty strong . . . just from being curious, I once glued two scraps of acrylic together with a dab of loctite marine, and couldn't get them apart, even after hammering and trying to pry them with a crowbar.