Choosing between zebra loach and clown loach for snail control

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Shadowplec6

Exodon
MFK Member
Oct 14, 2019
75
40
26
31
Cato, NY
I am trying to decide on which loach to get; Zebra or Clown? I have kept both at different times in the past but I never had them with snails because I knew they would eat them but I ,accidentally, got ramshorn snails in one of my tanks a year, which wasn’t a problem because I planned on raising them for my tanks especially for my snail eaters, but the snail eaters I have ( goldfish and koi) aren’t eating enough of them and now there are ramshorn snails in every single one of my tanks contains snails and they number in the thousands now! I have one tank setup for a betta which from what I understand will eat small snails and another tank setup for a pea puffer but I feel they are going to need help so I am looking into getting loaches again. I like both clowns and zebras, and the clown loaches large size is not an issue because I can move them with a larger tank once they get a little bigger and they are so adorable and playful their precious! I also like the zebra loaches, they have a really nice pattern and the ones I had before were pretty chill and acted a lot like my clown loaches. I have considered mixing them into a good sized group but I am not sure if they would get along with each other since they are different species? I know I will have to separate them when the clowns get too big to be with the zebras but that won’t be a problem. They will be the only bottom-dwellers in their (grower) tank and they will never run out of snails, the tank that the invasion started in is a tank that I can’t put snail eating fish in for fear that they will eat my shrimp and I don’t care for assassin snails and would rather not have them. So if I could get a little help with making a final decision on this it would be great since I am making my stocking lists now. Thank you!
 
Both will eat snails fine. I like the zebras as you can keep a much larger school in the same size tank. I have always enjoyed loaches more in larger groups. I watched a tank of 350 young clown loaches once and it was amazing. It definitely sold me on keeping loaches in groups. That said clowns will eat larger snails quicker.
 
Hello; Is the goal to have the loaches or is the goal to control snails? If you want the loaches regardless I will not further comment.
 
Really it is up to you. They have no problem being adopted out/sold to another fellow hobbyist if you change your mind. Regardless of what species. Good luck i like both.
 
Hello; Is the goal to have the loaches or is the goal to control snails? If you want the loaches regardless I will not further comment.
I want the loaches, the fact they eat snails is just an added bonus! I am a sucker for botia loaches and miss having them. ?I am just using the snails as an excuse to get them; I could handle the snails on my own but I would rather have the fish?
 
I've no experience with clowns, but I vote zebras. You can have a ton in a smaller tank and they are just super cool. In my tank they will hover, cruise, play like dolphins, or stand guard. Most personable fish I've had. Might submit this for POTM next week:

IMG_20190719_145050746.jpg
 
Clowns are more social and less aggressive.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com