To answer your original question on the Surgar...... And a little background..
Im in the automotive repair industry. Currently im a Service advisor for a very large and repsected privatly owned repair shop. The shops been in bussiness since 1973. I myself have been into the automotive repair bussiness for 28 years. Ive been a Master ASE certified technician/Mechanic, Owned my own fuel systems automotive repair shop, worked in dealerships and worked for private shops like I do now adising customers of their needs. Anyhow..........
The issue with surgar is this. It wont go in and instantly ruin an engine, it doesnt carmelize. In fact Surgar dosent disolve in gas very well at all. The issues with surgar is that if the vehicle has an in tank fuel pump, it can get into the pump assembly and damage the pump and cause failure. Baisically the same as sand getting into it. It can get into the fuel filter and plug it, and beyond that the only "Carmelizing" that can happen is the surgar if it makes its way to your fuel injection can over some time cause carbon. (take some surgar in a pan and heat it under a flame. It can melt then burn and turn into pure black hard as a rock carbon) This carbon can plug and damage injectors inside the engine causing fuel delivery issues. Eventually the worst that could happen is, youd have to replace expensive injectors, perform a carbon service on the fuel system, replace a fuel filter and replace a electric fuel pump.
And pouring rice into a gas tank................ Does nothing but make the rice saturate with fuel and swell.. It could get sucked into the fuel pump sock and clog it or ruin a fuel pump....... BUT its not going to do anything else as the rice does not disolve.