Flagtail Prochilodus – COLOR CHANGES through life-span

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
I just don't know. Blakewater Blakewater 's 2nd picture also has a very tall dorsal fin.
Beautifull fish, thanks!
What I've heard is theres two kinds of flagtails sold as Fei Feng. One supposedly has 7-8 bars in its tail and stay smaller while one has 11-12 bars in its tail and gets larger. I didnt know this prior to getting mine but thats just what Ive heard. Does it hold any merit? Thats up for debate
 
  • Like
Reactions: thebiggerthebetter
What I've heard is theres two kinds of flagtails sold as Fei Feng. One supposedly has 7-8 bars in its tail and stay smaller while one has 11-12 bars in its tail and gets larger. I didnt know this prior to getting mine but thats just what Ive heard. Does it hold any merit? Thats up for debate
I've no clue and here to learn. Would you link where you picked this up?
 
I've no clue and here to learn. Would you link where you picked this up?
It’s literally just been through word of mouth from other veteran keepers (20 yrs+) I didn’t even put much faith in it until what they were suggesting began coming to fruition in terms of growth in comparison to other friends flagtails that do have fewer “tail bars”. I just bought the fish as a “true fei feng” but then growth could just as easily be attributed to having an entire 500g to himself to clean
 
  • Like
Reactions: thebiggerthebetter
What I've heard is theres two kinds of flagtails sold as Fei Feng. One supposedly has 7-8 bars in its tail and stay smaller while one has 11-12 bars in its tail and gets larger. I didnt know this prior to getting mine but thats just what Ive heard. Does it hold any merit? Thats up for debate
Sorry to come back to the same post again. I just thought that the alternative and trivial explanation for this observation, right or wrong, is that bigger fish have more room to display more stripes, is all.
 
Sorry to come back to the same post again. I just thought that the alternative and trivial explanation for this observation, right or wrong, is that bigger fish have more room to display more stripes, is all.
Very possible. I've never taken the time to delve into all the research papers regarding flagtails like I have cichla. The only reasoning I could offer to refute this is that my flagtail had all 11 Bars when he was 3.5-4" and hasn't gained or lost any of them. But they could also just be like Datnoids in that while the pattern is a genetic trait, it can vary a bit from fish to fish.
 
  • Like
Reactions: thebiggerthebetter
We hear about difficulty recognizing between the 3 species supposedly in the hobby: Semaprochilodus insignis, S. taeniurus, and S. laticeps. Difficult to recognize in aquarium fish, since the characters are mainly about counts of scales and counts of rays on fins, not aquarium-possible characters.

We also hear about Red Tail, Yellow Tail, High Fin, Short Body, and other terms applied to “Flagtail Prochilodus” that may refer to anything from actual species, to varieties of single species; they may also partly refer to inter-specific variation due to provenance (actual geographic variation), but also to ontogeny (age and development of individual fish), and possibly varying conditions in aquaria.

In the pictures below there is a single fish, shown at various times over a 3-year span. I purchased it at ~ 2.5-3 inches in September 2017. He (she?) is about 10 inches today and very friendly. The first set of pictures are all around the same date, the adult pictures shown were taken sometime on 2019, and the last May 2020.
The main changes I can see include: 1) Spotting on body becoming much less with age, and the spots become proportionally smaller in larger fish; 2) Color of the dorsal fin changes dramatically, appearing less banded (and less attractive) in older fish; 3) Red coloration on caudal fin (tail) and anal fin becoming more intensely red with age. Tail on the young fish was more yellow than red, but the ventral pair of fins were red from the beginning.

Have you had your Flagtail for long? Have you noticed color or shape changes? Would you show pictures of your Flagtail of any type and color? Cheers!

View attachment 1420259

View attachment 1420260

View attachment 1420261

View attachment 1420262
Can these fish breathe air? Or do they need air pump?
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com