Frozen fish!

jjohnwm

Sausage Finger Spam Slayer
MFK Member
Mar 29, 2019
4,281
10,970
194
Manitoba, Canada
When I was a kid growing up in Alaska I met a family that was very active in the local aquarium club. Odd to think how things have changed as I haven't heard of anything like an aquarium club for decades but that's the way it was then.

Their name was Baleau IIRC and I think it was one of the parents that applied for and rec'd a permit from F&G to catch and keep a local fish known to be able to freeze, thaw back out and survive the ordeal. As I recall it was not an attractive fish by my Pineapple Swordtail standards of the time and I couldn't understand why anyone might want to keep one. They had it for several years and thawed it back to life in spring multiple times as I understood it.

There was a debate at the time about the existence of ice worms as well. Never paid much attention to that one.
That sure sounds like the Alaska Blackfish! It's not for the interior decorator fish crowd for sure; looks like the Incredible Hulk version of an Umbra mudminnow. I personally think they are very interesting...but I feel the same way about mudminnows, so...:)


coldwater fish such as lake trout and burbot travel extremely shallow in the winter since the whole water column is cold and they are no longer limited to staying below the thermocline. I target brook trout in 2-3 feet of water in winter. I think the water temperature is more dictated by vegetation and bottom composition during the winter than it is by depth. I have caught perch in 4 feet of water in vegetation at the start of winter but they transition to deeper water as the weeds die off shallow.
I'm not sure I see how those factors would affect water temperature. I agree about the fish moving deeper as winter progresses but I suspect it might be because of possible lower oxygen levels as the dead vegetation decays in the shallows.

The temperature difference between the shallow and deep water is much less pronounced in winter, when it's only a couple of degrees, as opposed to summer when it can be much greater.

We have good luck catching pike on deadbaits set right on the bottom in reasonably shallow water in late winter, close to ice-out. I think they move for brief periods into those areas looking for fish that have succumbed to low oxygen levels, because we rarely catch pike by "dead-sticking" at other times of the year. They also seem to fight much less when hooked then, which adds to the supposition IMHO that they are nearing their limits in terms of dissolved oxygen levels.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: SilverArowanaBoi

jjohnwm

Sausage Finger Spam Slayer
MFK Member
Mar 29, 2019
4,281
10,970
194
Manitoba, Canada
I'm loving this thread. To think I was b****ing and whining at catching rhads in 16 C water!
Lol, I'm bemoaning the fact that it will be at least a couple more weeks before I can drive my full-size pickup out onto the ice for fishing...:)
 

Friller2009

Aimara
MFK Member
Oct 27, 2021
979
1,581
134
Australia
Lol, I'm bemoaning the fact that it will be at least a couple more weeks before I can drive my full-size pickup out onto the ice for fishing...:)
My local fish club (ANGFA NSW) is having our Christmas part kinda meeting. Got a couple of displays I've set up and will be giving a little talk
Anyways, our plan was to have a barbeque, but that won't be happening as its going to be 44 degrees and 4% humidity, leading to a fire ban!
Anyways I for one am looking forward to Christmas, nothing better than an Australian christmas lunch, followed by your traditional christmas dinner!
 

Ogertron3000

Potamotrygon
MFK Member
Nov 6, 2017
1,383
3,021
164
Australia
Wow, did you and your girlfriend at the time ever contemplate venturing into the film making business? I think horror films would have been right up your street, lol.
I've been present for a couple of debacles similar to that; your common-sense approach is what I always preach, but many aquarists are simply too squeamish to practice it. They are totally committed to reducing suffering to zero, but unfortunately it's their own suffering about which they are concerned, and so therefore many fish get tortured to death by means that allow the aquarist to salve his/her own conscience because their hands stay clean.
The whole thing was a fiasco that could have been ended quickly but as jjohnwm jjohnwm says it was more about my GF not getting upset or getting her hands dirty.
I can only imagine the drama if we tried the hot needle, missing the brain over and over again until the fish had 12 holes in its head and eventually died from the trauma. Obviously i was the designated surgeon which was when i put a stop to the whole mess.

I have heard of goldfish surviving under ice in frozen ponds in the UK and colder parts of the USA but I do wonder if we left it in the freezer overnight or even a few more hours until it was frozen solid that would have finished it off, i still doubt hte initial cooling down and freezing stage would have been painless and just "made the fish drift off to sleep", most probably it would have been very uncomfortable but a quick google search still shows lots of results recommending this method.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SilverArowanaBoi

Zmouvek

Exodon
MFK Member
Dec 2, 2022
96
67
26
a bottomless pit.
  • Haha
Reactions: SilverArowanaBoi
zoomed.com
hikariusa.com
aqaimports.com
Store