Has anyone kept yellow perch?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
79 degrees is considered the stress level for Yellow Perch and they prefer cooler waters. Are Perch native to AZ? They are a fish that changes water depth as the seasons change......we catch tons ice fishing here. Do not assume they will be happy in AZ.....Even in CT my pond reaches 90 degrees in late august and the perch would never survive.
 
Cool thanks, I figure at some point if I get one I’ll have to either upgrade my tank or rehome one or two fish as they get big. A crappie and walleye are two others I’ve been considering but the perch seems to be the best
Personally I wouldn't keep walleye unless ya have a 300g or bigger. As for crappie a 120-150g for a single fish would be alright I would think.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joshuakahan
79 degrees is considered the stress level for Yellow Perch and they prefer cooler waters. Are Perch native to AZ? They are a fish that changes water depth as the seasons change......we catch tons ice fishing here. Do not assume they will be happy in AZ.....Even in CT my pond reaches 90 degrees in late august and the perch would never survive.
Really? The perch here won't spawn untill the water temps reach upto 82-84°F, usually around late July. Granted I will say that temps in SD here do vary wildly from a day to day basis so maybe that's a factor in it. Generally when temps are at 76-78°f I tend to catch them at only 2ft deep at most but once spawning temps have been reached I won't catch them any shallower then 4ft.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joshuakahan
Really? The perch here won't spawn untill the water temps reach upto 82-84°F, usually around late July. Granted I will say that temps in SD here do vary wildly from a day to day basis so maybe that's a factor in it. Generally when temps are at 76-78°f I tend to catch them at only 2ft deep at most but once spawning temps have been reached I won't catch them any shallower then 4ft.
they spawn in the spring here in CT when water is colder.....they retreat during the summer and winter. we catch em at 15-20 feet during the winter.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Magnus_Bane
I figured, I think if I get anything, I’ll stick with the perch
Yeah if any native fish you'd want to steer clear would be minnows and bluegill. They like highly oxygenated water that stays cold. They do not handle temp changes easily at all. Think of em like discus, any change in the water temp and you'll have tons of dead fish.
 
79 degrees is considered the stress level for Yellow Perch and they prefer cooler waters. Are Perch native to AZ? They are a fish that changes water depth as the seasons change......we catch tons ice fishing here. Do not assume they will be happy in AZ.....Even in CT my pond reaches 90 degrees in late august and the perch would never survive.
My tank doesn’t get anywhere near 79, it’s room temp, but we run the ac at 73 8 months a year. $$$$ lol The tank stays pretty consistent at 74-75.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Magnus_Bane
they spawn in the spring here in CT when water is colder.....they retreat during the summer and winter. we catch em at 15-20 feet during the winter.
Huh, ig it just depends on what they are already used to for temps on how well they will tolerate it. Mine got along fine in the tank but I kept the tank at roughly the same temp that it is in early summer here. Only time I had problems with em was when my dad added a 1in mbuna to the tank, this lil tiny fish ruled the entire tank of predators with an iron fist. That was one of the few fish we ever had to feed to the cats just because of how aggressive it was. It was also our first time dabbling in cichlids.
 
Yeah if any native fish you'd want to steer clear would be minnows and bluegill. They like highly oxygenated water that stays cold. They do not handle temp changes easily at all. Think of em like discus, any change in the water temp and you'll have tons of dead fish.
,
ya no minnows for me There’s some Bluegill in the pond with the venustus. We mostly have green and bluegill as far as sunfish go. I had a CB bluegill but it was crazy aggressive, they stock bluegill in most of the lakes here and we get to 115-120 for most of the summer and it doesn’t get much below 100 at night July-Early September.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Magnus_Bane
Huh, ig it just depends on what they are already used to for temps on how well they will tolerate it. Mine got along fine in the tank but I kept the tank at roughly the same temp that it is in early summer here. Only time I had problems with em was when my dad added a 1in mbuna to the tank, this lil tiny fish ruled the entire tank of predators with an iron fist. That was one of the few fish we ever had to feed to the cats just because of how aggressive it was. It was also our first time dabbling in cichlids.
Damn, what type of mbuna? Some are insanely aggressive, others less.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com