Insurance coverage for aquariums

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
One question you want to ask your insurance provider if your policy is an HO3 or an HO5. HO5 policies are much broader and provide more coverage. Basically an HO3 will only cover claims if specifically listed in the policy while an HO5 will cover anything unless specifically excluded in the policy. Very important distinction. There are a few other “discount” types out there but the majority of HO polices will be one of the two.
Condo policies are a different animal as they are more of a glorified renters insurance policy and meant to cover the owner of the condo when there is a shortfall in the master condo association policy. Most believe it covers from the studs in but this is a simplistic definition.
Stated correctly above, most policies will cover sudden ruptures but if it can be proven damage has been occurring over an extended time frame (leaking pipe or aquarium) most insurance companies will decline coverage.
That being said liability is different. If you are found liable for damages caused to someone else’s property that will be covered. I would suggest everyone should carry minimum of $500k in liability coverage. Most policies can be increased to this for nominal premium, usually $25 per year or so.

Just reading the above post. Most policies will cover any personal property that is damaged from a rupture. The one shortfall maybe the tank itself as a carrier can argue that it is a manufacturer defect. But depending on the age of the tank this could lead to the insurance carrier going after the manufacturer for liability if it is a larger claim.

Post #64 is fairly accurate. One point insurance laws and regulations do vary state by state and obviously carrier to carrier. I have dealt with a aquarium sudden rupture and the majority of the resulting damage and mitigation was covered. If I remember correctly the livestock and tank were not.
 
Last edited:
This is a subject I seem to visit at some point every year. Last time I visited, I called current insurance policy and agent tried to assure me I was covered. Of course, I realize that if a tank failure happens at some point, the adjuster might have a different idea.

Tldr:
Please post if you have extra insurance for your tank or if you feel you're covered by your current insurance.

I've done a search on here and this post was interesting:

The rest of the threads I found focused on renters insurance.

We live in a condo with 3 floors beneath us. What amount of liability coverage would you want for that situation? I'm thinking I should increase mine to several hundred thousand?

Has anyone been able to get a special rider that specifies Aquarium damage? I think I read that someone claimed they supposedly got a rider attached with State Farm.

I also remember a post that said no matter what, fish won't be covered bc livestock/animals are never covered (though someone got corals replaced supposedly bc adjuster probably didn't realize corals are technically animals). I'm fine with that. I'm more worried about the damage to neighbors.

We had a plumbing leak cause damage to neighbors below and insurance covered that and it went smoothly but I fear Aquarium might be different.

Before I tackle this issue again, I'd just like to hear some feedback and hear some experiences people have had with this issue.

Thanks.
My wife is a litigation specialist for a commercial carrier, and specializes in construction defects, however spent the first half of her career in personal lines. She had one thing to say: agents are like used car salesman and just want to sell a policy. See if your agent has a claims rep on-site and make sure you ask specifically in your policy contract where it addresses the exact situations you’re concerned about and explain any and all policy exclusions that could lead to your carrier disclaiming coverage. Pay attention to your 1st and 3rd party coverages as well as your deductible amounts. Having an aquarium is different than a plumbing leak, as the plumbing is actually part of your home. There are policies available for your animals *depending* on the type of policy and honestly the state you’re in. Progressive and even Lemonaide might be able to help you out with a policy that better suits your needs, also shop around. ASPCA also offers pet insurance options and may at least be able to point you in the right direction.
 
I have looked at several pet insurance policies and have yet to see one that covers fish. There are certain companies like Lloyds that will write policies for crazy stuff but I think the premium would not be justified by the value of the fish. There are commercial policies that cover livestock (cows and horses) but obviously they are valued differently then a pet.

Funny. I wasn’t trying to sell a single thing......
 
Last edited:
I have looked at several pet insurance policies and have yet to see one that covers fish. There are certain companies like Lloyds that will write policies for crazy stuff but I think the premium would not be justified by the value of the fish. There are commercial policies that cover livestock but obviously they are valued differently then a pet.

Funny. I wasn’t trying to sell a single thing......
Are you an agent? No offense meant, just repeating what she told me
 
I don't remember exact payout but I think the water damage from the broken dishwasher (like when plumber came and tested it, water fished out of the bottom) was in the four figure range: I wanna say over $5k.

100g+ has gotta be over 100k?

The condo rules don't prohibit aquariums but they do specifically prohibit water beds. They probably wouldn't like a huge tank (they've seen current tank and said they didn't like it but it wasn't prohibited in rules). If I get a new tank, I'm hoping to get it in here without a lot of people seeing it...
Cover it with a blanket, when you bring it in. then they can’t say for sure what it is
 
This is a subject I seem to visit at some point every year. Last time I visited, I called current insurance policy and agent tried to assure me I was covered. Of course, I realize that if a tank failure happens at some point, the adjuster might have a different idea.
Where are you? Might hugely effect the decision.

There was a case here in Wellington where a tank burst, I don't remember any details on the tank, I think it was a freshwater tank that burst. It did $1 million+ damage to the apartment below.

Ah, found an article: https://www.stuff.co.nz/life-style/...in-wellington-gutted-after-fish-tank-accident
Was previously sold for $1.85 mill, afterwards gutted and selling for $550k.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jacob92677
Where are you? Might hugely effect the decision.

There was a case here in Wellington where a tank burst, I don't remember any details on the tank, I think it was a freshwater tank that burst. It did $1 million+ damage to the apartment below.

Ah, found an article: https://www.stuff.co.nz/life-style/...in-wellington-gutted-after-fish-tank-accident
Was previously sold for $1.85 mill, afterwards gutted and selling for $550k.

I'm in Illinois.


One question you want to ask your insurance provider if your policy is an HO3 or an HO5. HO5 policies are much broader and provide more coverage. Basically an HO3 will only cover claims if specifically listed in the policy while an HO5 will cover anything unless specifically excluded in the policy. Very important distinction. There are a few other “discount” types out there but the majority of HO polices will be one of the two.

Post #64 is fairly accurate. One point insurance laws and regulations do vary state by state and obviously carrier to carrier. I have dealt with a aquarium sudden rupture and the majority of the resulting damage and mitigation was covered. If I remember correctly the livestock and tank were not.

I'm going to call them tomorrow or Thursday. I have Liberty Mutual, and the website suggests my policy is an H06 policy but I'll find out for sure when I call them.

I'm learning a lot about this insurance from this thread, the other thread I linked, and some google searches.

I've created a list of questions I'm going to ask them. I'll ask about aquariums but as the thread said and as I remember from my last call two years ago, I already know I'll get the standard answer.

Here are the questions I have so far for them. If anyone has any additional suggestions, please let me know:

what H0x policy do I have?

how much does more liability coverage cost?

500k?

can you send me full policy terms so I can read them?

What are the limits on personal property claims (jewelry, firearms, phone)?

any riders concerning aquariums?

blanket jewelry coverage?
(OT regarding aquariums, but I just learned about this option. We have jewelry that is mostly in the safety deposit box but I see from reading that I might need to get extra coverage. I might actually wear some of the stuff in the box if I find this extra coverage reasonable. Otherwise, I guess it's safe in the bank. I also saw I need extra coverage for firearms possibly).
 
Cover it with a blanket, when you bring it in. then they can’t say for sure what it is

I'm hoping they'll think it's an 8 foot couch or something. Part of me wishes I was on the first floor so I could get as big of a tank as could fit through the sliding door and it would be easier to get in. I'm going to try to hire a professional installer so they can make sure this can get through doors and in elevator.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joshuakahan
HO6 is a condo policy. The two referenced above are for straight homeowners.
 
This thread got me down an insurance rabbit hole. I ended up researching firearms insurance.and jewelry insurance.

As for the condo insurance, I had a good talk with the agent. I had the policy info sent and there is nothing excluding aquariums or water furniture. Of courses as discussed, this doesn't mean that actually getting a claim paid would be easy.

I increased liability to $500k as recommended. It only cost an extra $5 a year. I discovered "loss assessment" insurance. While I don't fully understand if I need it, I added some coverage since that was also only $5 more a year.

I found another good thread:


Post #62 is a good summary of what this woman learned from her successful claim for damage caused by a broken tank. The whole thread is a good read.

The damage to her condo ended up being $50k. Her insurance initially denied the claim and she hired a private adjuster to fight them. A later post said her insurance tried to deny her three times before paying!
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com