Large Fish that Wont Eat Small Fish?

spitz006

Plecostomus
MFK Member
Dec 25, 2010
547
97
61
Allegan, MI
Other than Loricarid (pleco) catfish, is there any other large fish that won't eat small fish? Looking at setting up a large tank with small fish such as neon tetras and livebearers, but was curious if there were any larger fish that could go in there that woulnd't eat the small ones. Plecos of course, but anything else?
 

Stephen St.Clair

Potamotrygon
MFK Member
Jul 2, 2017
1,326
2,269
164
I keep Altus Tinfoils Barbs & Chocolate Cichlids w/ Columbian & Diamond Tetras.
The big boys ignore the Tetras, but it's important to remember that any fish with a large enough mouth has the potential to eat smaller tankmates.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joshuakahan

Something Fishy Here

Piranha
MFK Member
Aug 26, 2022
430
415
77
Depends on the small fish and depends on the individual big fish, I've had a few severums in the past that floated gracefully around the tank never messing with anyone, until I thought a small school of neons would look cool in there... it was an expensive snack for them. They don't have to be aggressive when they can slurp them down whole.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fallen_Leaves16

jjohnwm

Sausage Finger Spam Slayer
MFK Member
Mar 29, 2019
4,236
10,806
194
Manitoba, Canada
I had an Osphronemus gourami that would not even look at smaller fish, but I have read of others that couldn't be trusted with the little guys. Individual personalities vary. Aggressiveness has nothing to do with this; predation and aggression are two entirely different things. A friend had a pearsei cichlid that was equally inoffensive to small fish.

I guess a lot depends upon your definition of the term "large", referring to both the fish size and the tank size. In a big enough tank, a big enough predator usually won't bother with truly tiny fish because they are simply not worth the trouble to eat. There are plenty of pictures on MFK and elsewhere showing large Arowanas, Gouramis, Wolffish, Cichlids, etc. living in large tanks with a considerable population of tiny Guppies, Neons, etc. that just swim "under the radar", so to speak. The King of DIY has/had a large tank with a single large Arowana and a huge number of Neons or Cardinals; somebody on MFK has shown their tank housing a single large Wolffish (malabaricus?) living with a bunch of Guppies. It makes for a very cool display, IMHO.

And then, of course, there are...the real jerks. My Jelly Cat lives in a 200-ish gallon tank that is plumbed together with a 75-gallon tank housing a breeding colony of Green Swordtails. The 75 acts as the sump for the system, and new-born fry regularly manage to find their way all the way to the pump which then whisks them violently up and into the catfish's domain. I just leave them alone...hey, they've gotta take responsibility for the consequences of their own choices! :)...and I thought and hoped that they'd probably be okay, and would grow large enough that I could more easily spot and net them out. But...they don't. On more than one occasion I have been sitting and watching that tank, only to see a 1/4-inch Swordtail venturing too close to the wrong end of the 18-inch catfish. The big guy doesn't react at all, unless the fry comes too close...and then, just before it touches a whisker, there is that explosive GULP and the fry...along with a mouthful of plant material, a few snails, some sand and a quart of water...disappears. Then all that extraneous material is laboriously chewed and gummed and spit up a bit at a time...but the fry is gone forever.

The number of calories bound up in that tiny fish is probably 1/10 the number that the catfish expends when he does this. He is kept well-fed...but he is never sated. He's an idiot, plain and simple.
 

latapy10

Polypterus
MFK Member
Nov 9, 2019
438
434
87
38
Europe
Other than Loricarid (pleco) catfish, is there any other large fish that won't eat small fish? Looking at setting up a large tank with small fish such as neon tetras and livebearers, but was curious if there were any larger fish that could go in there that woulnd't eat the small ones. Plecos of course, but anything else?
I once saw a huge labeo chrysophekadion about 0,4 m long with some neons and livebearers in the same tank.
i was surprised but it looked like it really worked.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fishman Dave

esoxlucius

Balaclava Bot Butcher
MFK Member
Dec 30, 2015
3,910
14,959
194
UK
This big fella, a 20" RTGG, as you can see, is surrounded by potential snacks, and he never bothers any of them!!

But with this species it could so easily have gone the other way. They are unpredictable. I just got lucky.

IMG_20221209_201439_HDR.jpg
 
zoomed.com
hikariusa.com
aqaimports.com
Store