i've been doing some research on reef tanks and found a few places recommending just a skimmer, live rock, and sand. was wondering how effective this is? for a beginner would a filter be a better choice?
reef tank without a filter
- Thread starter dreamandscheme
- Start date
yes lol most no filter tanks are use with a filter in the start and then after the bio-load is ready and able then u can take the filter out (or atleaset thats what i have done) but u still need the proper flow dont forget 
that is exactly what I have. I have a 90 with a sump, asm g4 skimmer, and a small refuge. I recommend it this way, filters such as canisters can raise ph ammonia etc...when not replaced on a regular basis. I sometimes throw in a carbon pack, and I vodka dose (which is the single best thing I have ever done for my reef).
I'm not sure if I believe the hype about not running a filter, Detritus is going to decay and produce nitrates either way whether you use a filter or not. The upside of using a filter is you can filter out the detritus and clean out your filter thus removing the detritus before it has a chance to decay and turn to nitrate.
I dunno, thats just my logic.
I dunno, thats just my logic.
So do I need a filter on my 45g reef tank? It's been running for six months and everything seems to have stabilized. I have two hang-on filters a skimmer and a powerhead. Do I need all that?
My stock is in my tank set-up.
<
My stock is in my tank set-up.
<