I have kept platys with cichlids as well. Platys usually stay smaller (unless you can find jumbo platys) in comparison to mollys or swordtails so they tend to get a little more beat up on. Also, platy fry are much smaller than molly fry so there's that.
I have been really wanting to go with some swordtails and give them a shot since I have never kept them before. I think it really comes down to personal preference and color choice for you but don't forget the platys won't get as big as mollys or swordtails.
I have been really wanting to go with some swordtails and give them a shot since I have never kept them before. I think it really comes down to personal preference and color choice for you but don't forget the platys won't get as big as mollys or swordtails.