What's the deal with Chinese Highfin Sharks?

krichardson

Bronze Tier VIP
MFK Member
Jun 19, 2006
27,750
14,990
480
Datnoid Island
If they are just gonna discard them as adults they might as well genetically engineer those fish to remain small for the rest of their lives
We already have enough deformed short bodied fish in the hobby.If they are so undesirable as adults then perhaps they should not be in the hobby at all.

So just because they don't look "pretty" they should be genetically altered to stay smaller so they look better?
.....as you can see,this is the thread that I meant to post in.
 

fishhead0103666

Alligator Gar
MFK Member
May 14, 2018
6,136
7,187
188
youtu.be
Ahh, I was confused but I thought that was what you meant Krich.
 

Deadliestviper7

The Necromancer
MFK Member
Aug 6, 2016
7,421
4,175
178
30
He’s a child kids don’t go to bars!
He's not a child, just can't drink yet, he can fight and die in the military, but can't enjoy a beer.


Back on subject: High fin sharks are slow growers so adults can be worth a bit, great for ponds, some people keep them year round in states like Alabama and California , I think they'd be great for a pond here in az
 
  • Like
Reactions: fishhead0103666

Cowturtle

Peacock Bass
MFK Member
May 2, 2016
336
763
115
Cincinnati
I
He's not a child, just can't drink yet, he can fight and die in the military, but can't enjoy a beer.


Back on subject: High fin sharks are slow growers so adults can be worth a bit, great for ponds, some people keep them year round in states like Alabama and California , I think they'd be great for a pond here in az
I know people that keep them just fine year round here in Kentucky too we rarely get 3 or 4 inches of ice on the surface and they still do alright.

Here's a pic of some wild ones fully colored up.

hifin.jpeg
 

Dloks

Potamotrygon
MFK Member
Feb 5, 2011
2,020
3,065
164
in a car
He's not a child, just can't drink yet, he can fight and die in the military, but can't enjoy a beer.


Back on subject: High fin sharks are slow growers so adults can be worth a bit, great for ponds, some people keep them year round in states like Alabama and California , I think they'd be great for a pond here in az
Uganda have 6 year olds in guerila military, are they adults too?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Deadliestviper7

thebiggerthebetter

Senior Curator
Staff member
MFK Member
Dec 31, 2009
16,400
14,555
3,910
Naples, FL, USA
If they are just gonna discard them as adults they might as well genetically engineer those fish to remain small for the rest of their lives
First of all, groundless generalization is senseless. We know no statistics of how many survive into adulthood and exactly what people do with them. I am yet to see a single adult Chinese Hifin for sale anywhere, including on CL, here in the MFK Marketplace, Aquabid, Ebay, LFS, on-line vendors, etc.!!!

No one in their right state of mind would kill a 2'-3'-4' Hifin just because they can't house them anymore or because they lost their juvi colors. First, the conscience. Second, the attachment. Third, mister $$$. If anyone kills theirs, it's most likely because they need to up their meds or they are the sadist kind.

I've no idea why fishhead0103666 fishhead0103666 would blurt out what he said - most reasons he gave were sane and fine but the killing was an utterly senseless thing to say. I am pretty sure he was just hypothesizing without any basis whatsoever. And look what such "innocent" blurting brings about. An even far more hair-raising blurts about genetic engineering "to help the ephemeral suffering and solve the problem that doesn't exist".

Second, many fish go through this process, e.g., Distichodus species, Leiarius pictus catfish, etc. If you don't like what your fish looks like anymore, find a new and right home for it. You are lucky it is not a cat or a dog or a parrot but the responsibility is still the same - whatever living being you took in, you take responsibility for its well being. Period. Next time do research and don't get the fish that you won't like for its lifetime. It's not a pet's fault you commit irresponsible choices and actions.

Genetic engineering brings about an unfathomable amount of suffering, some already evident, other is yet to be discovered and shown. In an analogy, let's say there are way too many people of the planet and the nature is suffering, the ecosystems are on the brink of collapse. We need to start culling the people or genetically modify them so they eat less, have lesser needs, die sooner or are born sterile.

Anyone who shoots dead a hitler like that would do the humankind a favor.

I'd say lots more but I'll step on my throat now.
 
Last edited:
Sep 24, 2017
917
306
77
21
Pennsylvania
First of all, groundless generalization is senseless. We know no statistics of how many survive into adulthood and exactly what people do with them. I am yet to see a single adult Chinese Hifin for sale anywhere, including on CL, here in the MFK Marketplace, Aquabid, Ebay, LFS, on-line vendors, etc.!!!

No one in their right state of mind would kill a 2'-3'-4' Hifin just because they can't house them anymore or because they lost their juvi colors. First, the conscience. Second, the attachment. Third, mister $$$. If anyone kills theirs, it's most likely because they need to up their meds or they are the sadist kind.

Second, many fish go through this process, e.g., Distichodus species, Leiarius pictus catfish, etc. If you don't like what your fish looks like anymore, find a new and right home for it. You are lucky it is not a cat or a dog or a parrot but the responsibility is still the same - whatever living being you took in, you take responsibility for its well being. Period. Next time do research and don't get the fish that you won't like for its lifetime. It's not a pet's fault you commit irresponsible choices and actions.

Genetic engineering brings about an unfathomable amount of suffering, some already evident, other is yet to be discovered and shown. In an analogy, let's say there are way too many people of the planet and the nature is suffering, the ecosystems are on the brink of collapse. We need to start culling the people or genetically modify them so they eat less, have lesser needs, die sooner or are born sterile.

Anyone who shoots dead a hitler like that would do the humankind a favor.

I'd say lots more but I'll step on my throat now.
Yeah, a lot of fish are messed up from being genetically engineered/modified


 
  • Like
Reactions: thebiggerthebetter
zoomed.com
hikariusa.com
aqaimports.com
Store