8 year old BD Male passed away.

Black_Diamond

Candiru
MFK Member
Oct 6, 2017
109
72
46
42
Reno, NV
Your thinking about this is backwards. Previously, you did not do water changes when you needed to and now you’re feeling pressured to do water changes when you shouldn’t.

At this stage of your cycle, if you remove the available ammonia and nitrite by doing water changes, you are effectively removing the food source that the bacteria need in order for the colony to increase in size.
Your nitrate level is getting higher, which is an indication of the conversion of the available nitrite Into nitrate. The nitrate should always be getting higher when the bacteria are converting toxic waste efficiently. Providing your nitrite is decreasing which it is and your nitrate is increasing which it is your cycle is progressing.
Do not do any water changes until your ammonia and nitrite are at zero because by doing so you will short circuit your cycle.
Hows this looking to everyone?

IMG_8843.jpeg
 

danotaylor

Dovii
MFK Member
Jun 26, 2024
525
733
100
54
Okeana Ohio
Nitrite is better but nitrates are less instead of more. Looks like you did a water change 🤔
 

Black_Diamond

Candiru
MFK Member
Oct 6, 2017
109
72
46
42
Reno, NV
No I havent touched it for over a week. The only thing I can think of is that the drum filter is working overtime again, because when it turns and uses its spray bar you have to fill it back up with fresh water and you do about 2 gallons a day. Hence why I never did water changes in the past. My nitrates have never been a problem cuz im running a drum filter on 440 gallons I mean the tank doesnt get very dirty.
Im starting to get concerned that without some cery dirty fish in there the bioload will never be enough for the drum filter and itll be too clean always.
 

danotaylor

Dovii
MFK Member
Jun 26, 2024
525
733
100
54
Okeana Ohio
As your nitrite goes down your nitrate will go up. It’s how the biological process works. The drum filter will not remove nitrate and 2 gallons per day will not give you a measurable reduction in your test results.
Your bioload is small now with just the 2 oscars so it’s not gonna climb crazy high, but you had pretty high readings of ammonia then nitrite a week or so ago when you nitrate was reading close to 20. It should be less than that since you haven’t done a water change.
1 of the 2 bottles with the nitrate test is kinda oily and needs to be shaken very well before use to give you an accurate result.
 

Black_Diamond

Candiru
MFK Member
Oct 6, 2017
109
72
46
42
Reno, NV
As your nitrite goes down your nitrate will go up. It’s how the biological process works. The drum filter will not remove nitrate and 2 gallons per day will not give you a measurable reduction in your test results.
Your bioload is small now with just the 2 oscars so it’s not gonna climb crazy high, but you had pretty high readings of ammonia then nitrite a week or so ago when you nitrate was reading close to 20. It should be less than that since you haven’t done a water change.
1 of the 2 bottles with the nitrate test is kinda oily and needs to be shaken very well before use to give you an accurate result.
Oh interesting let me retest
 

Black_Diamond

Candiru
MFK Member
Oct 6, 2017
109
72
46
42
Reno, NV
As your nitrite goes down your nitrate will go up. It’s how the biological process works. The drum filter will not remove nitrate and 2 gallons per day will not give you a measurable reduction in your test results.
Your bioload is small now with just the 2 oscars so it’s not gonna climb crazy high, but you had pretty high readings of ammonia then nitrite a week or so ago when you nitrate was reading close to 20. It should be less than that since you haven’t done a water change.
1 of the 2 bottles with the nitrate test is kinda oily and needs to be shaken very well before use to give you an accurate result.
Oh **** you are right look at my nitrates after shaking and retesting!

IMG_8845.jpeg
 

danotaylor

Dovii
MFK Member
Jun 26, 2024
525
733
100
54
Okeana Ohio
Ta-dah 🤗
As expected, your nitrates are steadily climbing as the nitrite is consumed. You ammonia looks pretty much at 0. Once the ammonia & nitrite are at 0 and your nitrate has peaked you have a cycled filter.
Remember, when you add the FRT and then in December you add the ray you will have a mini cycle again as the bioload increases beyond your filters conversion capability. It will take a week or 2 where you will see ammonia & nitrite present again.
Use the Seachem Prime in the detox dosing and salt to keep your fish & turtle happy & healthy until the ammonia & nitrite are at 0 again, then do large enough water changes to keep your nitrates in the 5-60 range between water changes 👍🏼
 
  • Like
Reactions: Black_Diamond

Black_Diamond

Candiru
MFK Member
Oct 6, 2017
109
72
46
42
Reno, NV
Ta-dah 🤗
As expected, your nitrates are steadily climbing as the nitrite is consumed. You ammonia looks pretty much at 0. Once the ammonia & nitrite are at 0 and your nitrate has peaked you have a cycled filter.
Remember, when you add the FRT and then in December you add the ray you will have a mini cycle again as the bioload increases beyond your filters conversion capability. It will take a week or 2 where you will see ammonia & nitrite present again.
Use the Seachem Prime in the detox dosing and salt to keep your fish & turtle happy & healthy until the ammonia & nitrite are at 0 again, then do large enough water changes to keep your nitrates in the 5-60 range between water changes 👍🏼
Man I keep doing water changes at least every other day about 30% and I swear the nitrates are getting worse... ammonia and nitrites still good but man the nitrates are just theough the roof.
 

danotaylor

Dovii
MFK Member
Jun 26, 2024
525
733
100
54
Okeana Ohio
What do mean by “through the roof”?
Have you tested your source water for nitrates? My source water in Cincinnati has 20ppm nitrate out for the tap. The EPA allows for up to 40ppm in city drinking water.
Don’t forget that the bioload in your system is constantly supplying ammonia and nitrite to your beneficial bacteria which convert them into nitrate. In a fully cycled filter with a consistent bioload your ammonia & nitrite will read 0 as they are converted before they become detectable, but the nitrates should always be climbing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Black_Diamond

danotaylor

Dovii
MFK Member
Jun 26, 2024
525
733
100
54
Okeana Ohio
Did you let your ammonia and nitrite get to 0 as previously discussed before you resumed water changes?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Black_Diamond
zoomed.com
hikariusa.com
aqaimports.com
Store