Dwarf/Shortbody Redtail catfish

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
What's that? I'm not on FB and clueless.
Vickor im also on fb now under the name of vundu arapaima. I know your against it but the hobby is thrieving on there! You should try it.i am against the site generally hence the fish names as my profile....i have no interest in ppl's day to day updates or pics of what they are eating lol. But my news feed is just fish post after fish post which is buzzing with pics vids and tanks from around the world.
 
  • Love
Reactions: thebiggerthebetter
Thanks bro. I am not against FB use for advancement of one's fish knowledge and the hobby in general. I aim not to oppose something IDK anything or much about. Perhaps sometimes unsuccessfully. I just never have time for FB and IG. Barely find scraps of time for YT, MFK and PCF.

I know I am missing out on a LOTTTTT of stuff out there. As we say in Russian, can't hug the unhuggable. But I really want to... against my better judgment haha... Maybe you could be my fearless leader and help me set up my news feed right to filter out the chaff. I have an incognito account.

Are there fish experts of known status on FB who one can recognize immediately and effectively learn from, when one has very little time?
 
Vickor im also on fb now under the name of vundu arapaima. I know your against it but the hobby is thrieving on there! You should try it.i am against the site generally hence the fish names as my profile....i have no interest in ppl's day to day updates or pics of what they are eating lol. But my news feed is just fish post after fish post which is buzzing with pics vids and tanks from around the world.
+1 love fb mostly use it for fish sales have no personal life on there as dont care just want to see fish ??
 
I don't really keep monster fish anymore...not sure what I'm doing here of MFK :)...and I have only seen baby RTC a few times...but frankly I can't see what makes those fish in the video "short-bodies"...or, as they would have been called throughout most of my time in the hobby, "culls".

Can it be we have come full-circle in this nonsense? A valuable and desirable fish species is in the hobby; eventually some enterprising shyster finds a deformed/distorted/misshapen cull (oops, sorry, "shortbody" ? ) in a batch of this species, and rather than destroying it he decides to do some marketing doublespeak and try to sell it for more than a healthy fish. Miracle of miracles...he succeeds! Somebody who absolutely must have the newest shiny thing buys the critter, and so dealers start seeking out the culls (shortbodies!) and marking them up to high prices rather than using them as feeders as they would have in the past.

A subculture of freak-keepers eventually arises; demand grows; there aren't enough culls around to satisfy the demand, so some other shyster says to himself "Hmmm...I wonder if I can just take regular, normal, healthy RTC's and call them shortbodies? They're all pretty stubby at this size...who's gonna know?"

Is my cynicism reaching new heights, or is that what's happening here? Would some RTC expert look at those little guys and confirm or deny that they are what he says they are...i.e. culls...er, dang, shortbodies???
 
There are degrees of short-bodiedness. Proper ones have no or very little gap between dorsal, adipose and caudal fins. This is how you tell.

Totally agree with you on the above but there people who want them and they are free just as we are free and it's not illegal (yet) to keep a freak pet fish...
 
The cleanest short body phantom around
His name is fat boy only grew 12 inches in 12 months but was the size of a thumb nail when I got him.
I love short bodies that aren’t deformed eve
N if they are the runts of the litter.
1741659133013.png
 

Attachments

  • 1741659376143.png
    1741659376143.png
    788.8 KB · Views: 4
  • Love
Reactions: danotaylor
The cleanest short body phantom around
His name is fat boy only grew 12 inches in 12 months but was the size of a thumb nail when I got him.
I love short bodies that aren’t deformed eve
N if they are the runts of the litter.
View attachment 1558527
Not a fan of SB’s but since his head and face appear normal he looks really cool! He was super cute as a kitten 😹
 
  • Like
Reactions: M3AN ONE
MonsterFishKeepers.com