Green terror or Flowerhorn

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Green Terror or Flowerhorn

  • Green Terror

    Votes: 18 72.0%
  • Flowerhorn

    Votes: 7 28.0%

  • Total voters
    25
Yes, I read there are about 3 different types of Green Terrors, but the one with the white on the tip of the fins were the first ones named Green Terrors, if that is correct. So do all types have the same temperament etc?

Read that some guy had both the gold, and the white, and the white types were much more aggressive.

Plus I read that the gold can grow up to 12 inches and the white can only grow up to 8-9 inches.
 
Yes, I read there are about 3 different types of Green Terrors, but the one with the white on the tip of the fins were the first ones named Green Terrors, if that is correct. So do all types have the same temperament etc?

Read that some guy had both the gold, and the white, and the white types were much more aggressive.

Plus I read that the gold can grow up to 12 inches and the white can only grow up to 8-9 inches.

It's convoluted and a bit complicated at first. Here is a good summary I copied from another thread on this forum. I don't know how to link from one thread to the other while browsing on my phone so I am using good old copy & paste:

This comes up often...

Stalsbergi as the 'true' or 'original' green terror is a misconception.

The basic order is: White edged rivulatus (Ecuador) showed up in the hobby first in the 1970s. Soon, also 1970s, came wild collected gold edged rivulatus. These were given the nickname "green terror" --the question at the time was: Are they rivulatus? Meanwhile there were also photos of what are now stalsbergi circulating. 1982-- a German article called what we now call stalsbergi (Peru) 'the green terror that isn't', being a third fish different from the those originally given the nickname 'green terror' (the Ecuador white and gold edged fish). So, the question for some became is this the true rivulatus?
---Source: Here, article by Wayne Leibel, biologist and cichlid expert who has written more than one article to clear up the confusion.

S0-- one reason so many have it wrong is at one time stalsbergi was considered the true rivulatus-- not the same thing as the true green terror. In fact, some older books and articles (some of which I have or had) had photos of the Peruvian fish (stalsbergi) captioned as the "true rivulatus" and from this a number of hobbyists concluded and spread the idea it was also the true green terror (which, based on this, I also started to think at one point). BUT-- the Peruvian fish turned out not to be rivulatus, so it's been named stalsbergi. The Ecuador fish is rivulatus.

There's also another similar, reportedly slightly smaller, fish from Ecuador: Andinoacara blombergi.

Imo I don't have an issue with calling stalsbergi green terrors also. It's just a nickname and, according to sources I've seen, some countries don't call any of them green terrors. But it would be more accurate to call stalsbergi Peru green terrors if you want to distinguish them from rivulatus, not the 'original' or the 'true' green terror.

In summary, A. Rivulatus comes in a couple of different colours. The white seamed "Silbersaum" and the yellow orange seamed "Gold Saum". Both are Rivulatus. Both can produce offspring of the other colour variant (so I have read), and apparently the white seamed fish can change colour and become yellow/orange when they age. Not sure if this colour change goes the other way.

The other white edged fish is A. Stalsbergi - the one being discussed in the quote I copied & pasted above.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for all the inputs guys. I ended up getting a baby Green Terror. It's eating, doing good, and being quarantine. It is only an inch. There were two other same size Green Terrors, a parrot, and a Firemouth in the same tank at the store. They just got the Green Terrors in the same day. They were chasing one another and being aggressive. They were also being aggressive towards the larger Firemouth.
 
unless ur flowerhorn is very passive or you have a big densely decorated tank a green terror will struggle .. a red terror might cope
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com