From research and collection, no such Orange Head Eartheater exists in the Rio Araguaia and is most likely a variant from the Rio Arapiuns. Heiko Bleher covers this in a thread on an Australian forum. The Rio Arapiuns is a blackwater Tapajos affluent, meaning that most collections could very well be of this different variety but end up just being labelled as the Tapajos variety, even though to an experienced eye the specimens can be quite different in colouration.
http://www.perthcichlid.com.au/forum/index.php?showtopic=24039&st=0
The Araguaia name comes as a result of Weidner's listing in his book South American Eartheaters, even though this collection point was simply (and seemingly incorrectly) traced back through other keepers and breeders.
Sticking with it for now until the fish are properly and scientifically classified. Mind you I still find it quite humorous that everyone lists their Tapajos variants as "Red Heads", with this being a prominent method of identification between the two species. A quote from Heiko from that thread:
The
true Tapajos as far as I can tell from experience with them here in Australia, and from what Heiko has written, are truly Orange Heads. It makes sense that a blackwater species such as the specimens in my photographs display more vivid colouration in the head (with no disrespect intended for the Orange/Copper gradient colouration of the Tapajos variety)
Perfect example above (not my fish, Keith/fella/chevguy, an Australian keeper who I believe has sold up unfortunately).
Left is what we know as the Araguaia variant, in a breeding colouration that's not at full intensity. Right is an F0 Tapajos male in breeding colouration.