kmill you are probably just not feeding enough. Post a pic.
Tien hope you are recuperated by now. I'm testing a small scrubber on a 10 FW...
...feeding one cube a day, no water changes, topoff with unconditioned tap water, zero ammonia/nitrite/nitrate. I add mono potasium phosphate in an attempt to grow thicker hair algae, because FW tends to grow longer and thinner, which can fill up your drain.
The only scrubber currently available is the SM100...
http://www.algaescrubber.net/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=502
... there is nothing "sized" currently for a 500. However, having multiple small scrubbers is much better than one big one. Bigger display tanks have more money in livestock, and need more reliable and consistant filtering. By having multiple smaller scrubber screens, pumps and lights, you always have one scrubber grown (and filtering) while waiting for the other one(s) to start growing again after being cleaned. And the more you can put the multiple scrubber parts in different "areas", the better, so that no matter what happens to one, you will always have the other(s). For example, put one scrubber on a different fuse/breaker than the tank; use a separate pump for each, or use a pump on one and the overflow on another; set one on the sump and another on the display, etc.
If your tank is new and is not yet stocked, you can always just start out with one scrubber and keep it that way until you're livestock and feeding are too much for it to handle. You will know it is time when you can measure any nitrate or phosphate at all.