REVIEW:Fluval FX5 vs Eheim Pro3 compared

STATMATT

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Jan 4, 2010
9
0
0
Washington, DC
I enjoyed this post. Minus the overwhelming bias for Eheim, I've purchased 2 FX5's for (drumroll..... 299.99 each from Amazon!) for my 150gal African Chick Tank.

In the Aquarium Hobby Invention is the Creation of Necessity. I'll look into the mods and judge if it is something I want to do.

Primary interest to me is creating flow. Using sand as a substrate, I need something that will kick up the detris on the Aquarium Floor to be sucked up by the Intakes. I'll have the filters on timers opposite the Auto Feeding cycle, this should give the fish ample time to gobble the food prior to being sucked into the uptake. Especially with the 2-3 minute Purge Whatchamacallit.

Prior to these 2 FX5s I've had 3 Rena XP3s on this tank. I like the XP3 as it is easy to use and I clean two skip one. Although I think the better method would have been to have each dedicated to Mechanical Filtration, two further dedicated to Biological Filtration and one dedicated to Chemical Filtration. The only prob here is pulling out all your bio material each time you wash the foams of the mechanical.

I learned the lesson the hard way about cleaning the sand with a water pump, disturbing all the sand at once... the release of those bubbles killed my fish! Nitrates skyrocketed, and I looked stumped as to why my fish were dying one at a time...

My plumbing plan is to plumb a 1" PVC manifold with 1/2" inline outputs onto the back of the Aquarium 1 " above the sandbed floor. This will hopefully in turn keep the detris circulated and suspended on the tank bottom for suck up into the intakes.

If anyone can direct me to posts on flow in large tanks, I'd appreciate it.

I also think this should be a sticky.
 

DJC776

Exodon
MFK Member
Sep 16, 2006
323
1
27
Norfolk, UK
On my 12 foot oddball community I went for a Oase Filterclear which is packed full of sponge. This is powered by an Oase Aquamax pump.

I then have an Eheim that feeds into a 12 foot by 6" x 6" glass trough on the rear glass tank brace tat is full of a biological medium including the heaters in the last 18".

Have just bought an Eheim 2080 as a back up on the system
 

jakepittbull

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Jul 31, 2010
63
0
0
ireland
GREAT REVIEW THANKS !
are these two the best in this class, are there any other options ?
 

dreamlover

Feeder Fish
Aug 21, 2010
3
0
0
Singapore
I am an eheim user for several years. Basically very good quality products including their pro2. However there were problems with the main seal & water leaks top of filter which can be repaired or replaced.

Can any user provide feedback on quality & repair issues faced so far for FX5 vs 2080 including running duration so far.

Thanks.
 

vfrstephen

Gambusia
MFK Member
Nov 8, 2007
477
1
16
Timbuktoo
dreamlover;4401924; said:
I am an eheim user for several years. Basically very good quality products including their pro2. However there were problems with the main seal & water leaks top of filter which can be repaired or replaced.

Can any user provide feedback on quality & repair issues faced so far for FX5 vs 2080 including running duration so far.

Thanks.
I have had 2 fx5s running on my 180gallon for over 3 years so far and never replaced anything, no leaks and very quiet.
 

dreamlover

Feeder Fish
Aug 21, 2010
3
0
0
Singapore
vfrstephen;4402361; said:
I have had 2 fx5s running on my 180gallon for over 3 years so far and never replaced anything, no leaks and very quiet.
How often & how many times you opened FX5 for cleaning ? Never changed the main lid seal before ?
 

vfrstephen

Gambusia
MFK Member
Nov 8, 2007
477
1
16
Timbuktoo
dreamlover;4408190; said:
How often & how many times you opened FX5 for cleaning ? Never changed the main lid seal before ?
I clean them every 8 weeks or so, no never changed the seal.
 
zoomed.com
hikariusa.com
aqaimports.com
Store