GLASS VS. ACRYLIC

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
from http://www.tenecor.com/info_lib_2.html


Acrylic vs. Glass Aquariums & Why Tenecor?
Customer's frequently ask Why Acrylic? and Why Tenecor Acrylic Aquariums? Hopefully this section answers some of your questions about the advantages of an acrylic aquarium and why you should do business with Tenecor.
WHY AN ACRYLIC AQUARIUM?
An acrylic aquarium is half the weight of a glass aquarium.
It's easier to ship, move, and set up your aquarium.


Acrylic fish tanks are several times stronger than glass aquariums.
An acrylic aquarium will not shatter, crack, or leak like glass tank can.

Acrylic distorts much less and is clearer than glass.
If a transparent object is surrounded by another material that has the same index of refraction, then the speed of light will not change as it enters the object. No reflection and no refraction will take place, and the object will appear invisible and without distortion, even at increased viewing angles. In addition to having a slight green tint, glass has an index of refraction that is considerably different from water. Clear acrylic panels have almost the same refractive index as seawater so there is no bending of light as it passes from the acrylic into seawater, providing better and brighter color and sharper shapes in acrylic aquariums. The huge viewing windows in large public aquariums and oceanariums can be more than 12 inches thick, but because they are made of acrylic, they afford a very clear view of the water and ocean life they enclose. Acrylic also allows better penetration of your system lighting, which is especially important for reef systems.

Acrylic insulates better than glass.
Acrylic controls water temperature fluctuations, one of the primary reasons for fish stress, disease, and death. Glass conducts heat and cold causing more temperature fluctuations.

Acrylic aquarium seams are stronger than glass aquarium seams.
Acrylic seams are molecular bonds and actually stronger than the acrylic itself. Silicone seams used on glass aquariums can dry out and weaken over time.

Seams in acrylic aquariums are visually superior to glass aquarium seams.
The seams of acrylic fish tanks are polished and nearly invisible. Silicone seams are clearly visible and have been known to discolor when exposed to certain fish medications.

Acrylic is easily refinished.
If glass scratches it can not be repaired. Acrylic can be repaired with a variety of scratch removal kits. Even internal scratches can be repaired without removing the fish or water.

Custom aquarium designs are possible with acrylic.
Acrylic can be formed to create interesting aquarium designs which you won't find with glass aquariums.

WHY TENECOR ACRYLIC AQUARIUMS?
Tenecor's Reputation.
Tenecor has been in business in the acrylic aquarium industry for nearly 20 years. We have been a pioneer in acrylic fabrication techniques and custom designs. We are not perfect, but we do stand behind our product and if we make a mistake we will correct it.

Tenecor's Lifetime Warranty.
By using only the finest domestic acrylic we are able to offer a limited lifetime guarantee. You will never worry about a disastrous aquarium leak again.

Tenecor's Selection.
We provide the widest selection of sizes, shapes, and styles. If you don't find what you want in our standard line of acrylic aquariums, we'll design a custom aquarium just for you.
Tenecor's Workmanship.
Our engineers and craftsmen are known for their attention to every detail. All Tenecor acrylic aquariums are manufactured in the U.S.A. with the finest materials available.
Tenecor's Standard Features.
Most of our standard aquariums are available with bent corners and colored backs at no extra charge. Our Simplicity Plus and Marine Ready aquariums include pumps and bio-media for one low price. Other companies charge a premium for these added features.



</B>
spcr.gif
 
well, i have just been running around panicking,trying to find something to quick fix my smaller glass tank...my other half accidentally dropped a glass jar, and in the process of trying to catch it, further propelled it into the front of the tank...the glass jar was victorious and came out winner,it took a fair chunk out of my tank ....then, water started to pour...luckily i had some aquarium silicon and some acrylic bits from cutting out the cover of a sump...so acrylic saved the day......lol

glass jar v glass aquarium,not a good outcome
glass jar v Acrylic aquarium(hypothetical),bounce off, some scratching(could be buffed out)
 
The highest quality optical medium for viewing is proven every time the Keck, Gemini, or Hubble telescopes take a picture. NASA spent $65,000,000
on a 2500 lb, 8ft diameter disc of GLASS so we could see across the universe. Polished over an 8 month period, the mirror was declared to be the smoothest surface ever created by man. Telescopes, cameras, webcams, binoculars, and everyday glasses made with plastic optics are garbage. Plastic is a solid.........Glass is a liquid this makes a difference.
 
Thought I would share my email response from glasscages.com -

I am interested in purchasing a 150Gallon acrylic tank 60x24x24. It does not show the "buy this online" button. Does this mean I will have to call to place this order?
Also is it possible to see a picture of this item? I am interested in the top bracing of this tank. Many acrylic tanks have small openings on the top, I was hoping to get as close to glass tank look as possible (in regards to the size of the openings on top)
I am aware that acrylic is more easily scratched then glass, but how much easier? Are there options available for the type of acrylic that will be used? Maybe one that is more scratch resistant. I have been told that scratches are easily buffed out of acrylic. Will maintenance instructions come with the tank explaining how to do this? If not would someone be able to direct me somewhere to get the buffing instructions after I place the order?
Finally, what would be the cost to have this tank and stand shipped UPS to area code XXXXX (NJ).

Any other information I should know before ordering would be appreciated.

Thank you in advanced for your help, and I apologize for all the questions. This would be my first acrylic tank.




Glasscages response -

I can answer all your questions about acrylic quickly. It scratches easily and quickly. When buffing out you get a fuzzy spot. Acrylic has it's place but when possible we suggest glass in the size range your mentioning.

All orders have to be finalized on the phone.

60 x 24 x 245 tall glass aquarium $ 495.00

24' tall oak stand $ 350.00

30" tall oak stand $ 425.00

--------------------------------------------------

Shipping cost to Carteret freight terminal is $620.00

OR

Pick up from our truck in white Plains NY costs $ 125.00

Thank You,
glasscages@gmail.com

www.glasscages.com

For further info or to order call 615-446-8877 (9:00AM - 5 PM Central Time - Monday through Friday only)
 
Well I have an acrylic tank and a glass tank. SO far so good on the scratch department, none to speak of touch wood even though my large pleco likes to slide across it. And I have to admit I unconciously treat my glass tank more gingerly even though it is alot small than my acrylic tank.
 
It all comes down to the quality and thickness of the acrylic; basically you get what you pay for. The reason I went for acrylic is because it's clearer than any glass, including Starphire or low-iron glass.


TCZeli, Euro-brace is what you have in mind in terms of the top openings. However, that will also mean you will need to go with thicker acrylic to avoid bowing.
 
I am curious as to how much more expensive these acrylic tanks are that are more 'scratch proof" due to better quality acrylic than "normal" acrylic.

the argument seems to be that acrylic tanks in north america are not good quality and are therefore easier to scratch.

if so, what kind of price difference are we talking for these better quality tanks?

twice as much?

three times?

just curious.
 
I say it just depends on what you want to do with your tank. If you go reef I say glass all the WAY!!!!!! But if you anything over a hundred gallons go acrylic. All tanks that Ive done over 100 gallons have been acrylic. And dont be afraid of the scratches theres simple kits that remove them from outside and in. Or what we use are orbital buffing wheels. Always makes them look new.
 
Glass is more clearer but Id go for acrylic though it scratches easily you can buff it anyways will not be perfect but will still look good and last long I'll say practical in lots of ways.
 
So let's say I decide to build a plywood tank, waterproofed with fiberglass, that's 4' long x3' wide x2' deep. should I use a glass or acrylic panel on the front? I know I could use silicone to seal if I use a glass panel, but what would I use if I used acrylic?
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com