cchhcc;2648308; said:Several photos on fishing sites, and the experience of collectors and researchers.
If the guy in the hat is in the 5'6"-5'10" range, this fish seems to fit the bill:
Of course, that doesn't mean all fish live long enough to get that large. Predation (especially from landlocked bull sharks in Lago Nicaragua) takes its toll on the large specimens, and some may not be genetically capable of topping the 30" mark.
reverse;2647963; said:SO in your opinion would say a statement like this was inaccurate? I felt it was............
"There are plenty of 18"+ Dovii on mfk....Are you crazy? Just because no one posts pics in this thread in 30 seconds, does not mean you are right...I have seen plenty of 18"+ dovii in members from Washington state's tanks...Ted comes to mind."
cchhcc;2707118; said:Regarding huge dovii, I've still only seen one (Twhittle comes to mind) or two posted next to a tape or something that provides scale (like Cichlidmaniac's arm).
I don't count the TN Aquarium fish as not many people can replicate that at home (and you still can't really tell how big they are, though they are certainly huge).
I don't doubt how big they can get. I just doubt that there are "plenty" 18"+ in home aquariums. I know of a few (Reagan, Dan -- ya'll out there?), and I've had a couple, but in my experience just about everyone adds an inch or two....... or five!
For a size comparison, I've had this umbee in my hands and on a ruler, so I know exactly how big he is..... and it's not 2 feet! : )
Keep in mind, I'm not trying to do anything with my comments other than point out just how difficult it is to provide these beasts with what they need to thrive. That they are so rare at large sizes says a lot.