Being softer than concreate it also means it will allow movement so should be less likely to crack. The ground water level is high where I am building so that kind of concreate would alow water in behind a liner causing other problems. This tanking will hold back a lot of pressure if it works trouble is I need to keep it wet while it sets. The pond I am replacing has a traditional pond liner … works very well but I have lost a couple of fish that have swam into creases and got stuck.