My 650g plywood tank also Wetsuit

sashimimaster

Blue Tier VIP
MFK Member
Mar 7, 2010
1,396
35
281
MI
Egon;5000804; said:
Your all set up for a trickle system. Pitch the valve and run your drain up to the surface of the water, whatever height you have now. Set a trickle of 1 to 2 gallons an hour going into your tank. The extra water will over flow into your drain. No moving parts or valves to fail. No power issues with buzzing solenoids and so on. Once set up you can forget about water quality issues. As the fish grow just increase the trickle. I test my water once a month if the water is clean I throttle back on the trickle a little or don't do anything. If the water is dirty I increase the trickle a little. This system is easyer on the fish too because your not slamming them with a 20% water change in an hour or so. Just one or two gallons an hour is easy on the fish.
Great....NOW you tell me :D. I would have to do extensive remodeling to do that. I would have to cut into the tank and install a new bulk head.

ATM I'm still wrestling with having a stable water level. For some reason I'm having some issues with balancing the outflow vs inflow. They way I thought I designed it was whatever overflowed from the tank would just get pumped back in. But it seems that the outflow is not quick enough to keep the big pumps fed. So the water level goes up and down.

Last night I had a little mishap. I didn't think there was enough water in the system so I added more. At one time it seemed like it was stable with one pump running. Then all of a sudden something broke loose and the outflow was way too fast and overflowed the sump.:cry: I had to clean up about 10 gals. It doesn't seem like much but as you know water gets everywhere. Wife wasn't too happy about that. :(

As I was cleaning up (had lots of time to think) the only conclusion I could come up with was there must have been some type of trapped air that was reducing flow. When that got pushed through it was like the dam broke. :WHOA:

So now I'm waiting for everything to dry out and then start it up again. Slowly.........
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pelli7358

sashimimaster

Blue Tier VIP
MFK Member
Mar 7, 2010
1,396
35
281
MI
AOmonsta;5001160; said:
Nice job on the tank. I'm rooting for you having no leaks.
Thanks bud. I think I'm good with the leaks. It's pretty solid. I've noticed no bowing or movement of any kind. Had a few small pipe joint oozing but for the most part pretty tight. :nilly:

On that thought I noticed that the joints that had some issues I used that Gorilla pvc glue. It was kinda free when I ordered my bulkheads. It says it doesn't need the purple cleaner so I didn't use it. And it's supposed to be no fumes and better for environment. I'm wondering if it had something to do with that. Now on the other joints I went with the traditional primer/cleaner then glue I've had no issues. Maybe it's that Gorilla glue :screwy:
 

Egon

Bronze Tier VIP
MFK Member
Jul 4, 2007
6,320
1,308
853
57
Tempe AZ
sashimimaster;5002028; said:
Great....NOW you tell me :D. I would have to do extensive remodeling to do that. I would have to cut into the tank and install a new bulk head.

ATM I'm still wrestling with having a stable water level. For some reason I'm having some issues with balancing the outflow vs inflow. They way I thought I designed it was whatever overflowed from the tank would just get pumped back in. But it seems that the outflow is not quick enough to keep the big pumps fed. So the water level goes up and down.

Last night I had a little mishap. I didn't think there was enough water in the system so I added more. At one time it seemed like it was stable with one pump running. Then all of a sudden something broke loose and the outflow was way too fast and overflowed the sump.:cry: I had to clean up about 10 gals. It doesn't seem like much but as you know water gets everywhere. Wife wasn't too happy about that. :(

As I was cleaning up (had lots of time to think) the only conclusion I could come up with was there must have been some type of trapped air that was reducing flow. When that got pushed through it was like the dam broke. :WHOA:

So now I'm waiting for everything to dry out and then start it up again. Slowly.........
I don't understand what your balancing? Maybe I have to go back and read this thread again.
The sump concept is simple: Water in the sump is pumped up to the tank. The extra water in the tank overflows back down to the sump. The cycle continues until power is lost then all the extra water drains back down to the sump. The sump needs to be large enough to hold this extra capacity. I run my sumps almost empty because of this. I don't have power loss often but when it happens I don't spill a drop of water. The sump fills to capacity until the power is turned back on.
 

sashimimaster

Blue Tier VIP
MFK Member
Mar 7, 2010
1,396
35
281
MI
I think the problem is the flow rate of the draining set up. The pumps are so fast that it drains the sump dry and it ends up cavitating before it can fill up. Then the water slowly rises and when it covers the top of the pump intake it starts pumping again. Within 5 seconds it's drained again and the cycle starts over.

Here's a picture of my set up. There is two intakes at the bottom and one intake at the top of the water level. They both connect to the overflow and down into the sumps. The water trickles through the pipes and the sump and gets to the end of the first sump. Then both pumps feed off of it and drain it dry. Is there something fundamentally wrong with my design? ATM I've got one pump off and the other one throttle down to like 10% and it's still over pumping. How do I increase the drain rate?

half wall.jpg

Sumps.jpg
 

Egon

Bronze Tier VIP
MFK Member
Jul 4, 2007
6,320
1,308
853
57
Tempe AZ
sashimimaster;5003706; said:
It's at 2". Shouldn't that be enough? The pump output is only 1.5".
The pump output is under pressure. Your moving more water through the 1.5" returns than the 2" gravity fed line. Any bends in the drain line will slow the water also. Any strainers in the drain line will slow even more. Go with three inch drain lines.
 

nfored

Fire Eel
MFK Member
Apr 4, 2008
2,597
14
68
Missouri
I have two 2inch drains at the top of my 220. I had it for a while powered by a t4000 calpump at 5'ft head should have been like 3000gph. I then reduced the pipe from the pump to the tank from 1.5 to 1", so the true flow was only likely 1000gph or something.

So I know none of this is reliant to you, but depending on how I had those drains drains setup and connected in the inside the drains would drain to slow or to fast.
 
zoomed.com
hikariusa.com
aqaimports.com
Store